A study of the intrinsic value of wilderness

This is the aesthetic of wilderness that has a special value. From his critique, Routley concluded that the main approaches in traditional western moral thinking were unable to allow the recognition that natural things have intrinsic value, and that the tradition required overhaul of a significant kind.

Life Support Systems Wilderness serves as critical habitat for animal and plant life. If relatively small, bioregional communities are to be home to flourishing human societies, then a question also arises over the nature of the laws and punishments that will prevail in them, and also of their integration into larger regional and global political and economic groupings.

Brennan and Lo This suggestion was inspired by a particular case in which the Sierra Club had mounted a challenge against the permit granted by the U. The platform was conceived as establishing a middle ground, between underlying philosophical orientations, whether Christian, Buddhist, Daoist, process philosophy, or whatever, and the practical principles for action in specific situations, principles generated from the underlying philosophies.

Regan maintains that certain practices such as sport or commercial hunting, and experimentation on animals violate the moral right of intrinsically valuable animals to respectful treatment. It depicts sustainability as a challenge and opportunity for the world to become more socially, politically and environmentally fair.

Some may see wild places as emblematic of other values they cherish, such as freedom and opportunity, or of Nature in general. These "relationalist" developments of deep ecology are, however, criticized by some feminist theorists. The idea that wilderness represents something nourishing and fortifying for the human spirit-even for those who never tread in one, and beyond any practical and scientific benefits-has been cited by many of its most famous proponents.

Under pressure from the charge of ecofascism and misanthropy, Callicott Ch. Commercial farming practices aimed at maximizing crop yields and profits, Carson speculates, are capable of impacting simultaneously on environmental and public health.

Unfortunately, it is not at all that simple, for while the feeling of intrinsic worth might be a datum of the experience of nature, we might still be called upon to determine whether this "feeling of intrinsic worth," is in fact worth having.

A study of the intrinsic value of wilderness

A persistent complication is that there continues to be no single agreed measure of biodiversity Maier Wilderness areas are generally larger than acres and have retained their primeval character. But within the plurality of feminist positions, other writers, such as Val Plumwoodunderstand the oppression of women as only one of the many parallel forms of oppression sharing and supported by a common ideological structure, in which one party the colonizer, whether male, white or human uses a number of conceptual and rhetorical devices to privilege its interests over that of the other party the colonized: The knowledge that wilderness will be around for your descendants to enjoy is "bequest value," while "option value" sometimes classed as its own category alongside direct and indirect values describes the opportunity for you to both directly and indirectly benefit from wilderness in the future.

How Wilderness Benefits You

Interpretations will vary, but must share certain general features and must flow from a consensus on the basic concept of sustainable development and on a broad strategic framework for achieving it.

On the other hand, the new animists have been much inspired by the serious way in which some indigenous peoples placate and interact with animals, plants and inanimate things through ritual, ceremony and other practices.

For example, the male is seen to be associated with the rational, active, creative, Cartesian human mind, and civilized, orderly, transcendent culture; whereas the female is regarded as tied to the emotional, passive, determined animal body, and primitive, disorderly, immanent nature.

From this perspective, answers to question 2 are informed by answers to question 1. It would appear that we have succeeded in identifying "the intrinsic worth of nature" as a component of the experience of nature -- at least to this observer. Meanwhile, some third-world critics accused deep ecology of being elitist in its attempts to preserve wilderness experiences for only a select group of economically and socio-politically well-off people.

Some authors have extended concern for individual well-being further, arguing for the intrinsic value of organisms achieving their own good, whether those organisms are capable of consciousness or not. However, because of the varieties of, and disagreements among, feminist theories, the label may be too wide to be informative and has generally fallen from use.

At the root of this alienation, they argue, is a narrow positivist conception of rationality—which sees rationality as an instrument for pursuing progress, power and technological control, and takes observation, measurement and the application of purely quantitative methods to be capable of solving all problems.

If disenchantment is a source of environmental problems and destruction, then the new animism can be regarded as attempting to re-enchant, and help to save, nature.

The Brundtland report puts less emphasis on limits than do Mill, Malthus and these more recent writers.

Philosophy Colloquium: Plato and the Value of Wilderness

If the government of a state has no intrinsic moral concern for the dignity and well-being of its citizens and its reason for raising or enforcing standards of health and security, for example, is merely that a healthier population and safer streets will generate a higher gross domestic product, more revenues for the state and more money and power for those running it, then it is unlikely that such a government will be motivated to protect those citizens who are considered too weak, too aged, or otherwise unfit to be productive in economic or other instrumental terms.

Here, our normal methods of discovering value seem inadequate to the task of recognizing these values. No-one, however, would regard insurance payments as replacing lost limbs, a loved one or even the joys of a cancelled vacation.

Meanwhile, the work of Christopher Stone a professor of law at the University of Southern California had become widely discussed. It is nothing but a giant machine, to be mastered to serve human purposes.

Moreover, the goals of animal liberationists, such as the reduction of animal suffering and death, may conflict with the goals of environmentalists.

Many rare and endangered species are indicators of ecological health, or they may play key roles in the balance of the ecosystem.

Environmental Ethics

As I reflect back upon my experience of wilderness, I seem to recall these features: In sum, wilderness benefits are many and varied.

One question central to virtue ethics is what the moral reasons are for acting one way or another. The everyday understanding of the concept is the biological species concept, that for sexually reproducing plants and animals, a species is a population of organisms that closely resemble each other genetically and are capable of interbreeding so as to produce fertile offspring.

Biospheric egalitarianism was modified in the s to the weaker claim that the flourishing of both human and non-human life have value in themselves. The "intrinsic value" of wilderness is that beyond any human evaluation or connection-wilderness for wilderness's sake.

These two different foci for the notion of intrinsic value still provide room for fundamental argument between deontologists and consequentialist to continue, albeit in a somewhat modified form.

It is wrong when it tends otherwise.important to me.

How Wilderness Benefits You

They have an intrinsic value and the right to be here. Period. I didn’t know much about wolverines until I read The Wolverine Way by Douglas Chadwick. Now I am totally hooked. Wolverines, the largest members of the weasel family, are designed for winter and live in northern mountain wilderness areas worldwide.

removing wildness from the discourse on wilderness we convert wilderness value from an intrinsic value into a distorted instrumental value. If we want to teach others that wilderness value means something more than a recreational, scientific, or economic opportunity, we need to include other ways of articulating this value in our education programs.

Abstract: One of the more radical views to emerge from the study of Environmental Ethics is the claim that come kinds of value are not anthropocentric. It is quite common to see this claim asserted as a justification for protecting particularly remote or barren pieces of wilderness.

The "intrinsic value" of wilderness is that beyond any human evaluation or connection-wilderness for wilderness's sake. There's no place on Earth entirely free of human impact, but in wilderness areas anthropogenic activities aren't the dominating forces.

Intrinsic Value in Wilderness?

Intrinsic value is the perceived or calculated value of a company, including tangible and intangible factors, using fundamental analysis. Also called the true value, the intrinsic value may or may.

allows American government to protect undeveloped land from development as part of the National Wilderness Preservation System; only % of U.S.

land is protected wilderness area (only % of the lower 48 states is protected wilderness area).

Download
A study of the intrinsic value of wilderness
Rated 4/5 based on 52 review